Banff Visitor Center Redevelopment

[Mull]

Mods, can we get a poll on this thread!

 

[DougB]

I know design is subjective but this competition did something right as all of the entries are solid

 

[adamyyc]

1 - Is fine, but it could honestly be a pavilion on the side of the TransCanada Highway. I don’t picture a lot of people being drawn to it outside of using the washrooms.

2 - This feels like an Iroquois longhouse (which is obviously geographically out of place). I don’t love the exterior roof design, but obviously love the dramatic interior that it facilitates. I don’t think this is quite my favourite, but I do think this one would probably offer Parks Canada the best shot at an additional revenue stream, because I can see the space being used regularly for events.

3 - Might be the most unique and ambitious design, but is probably too fragmented. I also think it has the best exterior public space/landscaping.

4 - This one could easily win because it checks all the boxes, but it’s also the most corporate/sterile design.

5 - See #1. I would check out the taxidermy grizzly on my way to the washroom.

6 - What the hell is even that?

Overall, I like 3 best, but it seems impractical. I think 2 or 4 will likely be the winner.

 

[CallmeCatbread]

I know design is subjective but this competition did something right as all of the entries are solid

This is what happens when we actually hold a design competition for something rather than just handing it off to whatever shitty firm has the most "qualifications" and lowest fee

 

[Makarov]

I like #2 and #3 the best. Least favourite are #5 and #6.